How to find broken backlinks and turn them into links you keep
TL;DR: Broken backlinks are links from other sites that point to a URL on your site that now returns 404. Find them by listing your top linked pages in Google Search Console and a backlink tool, then checking which of those URLs return errors. Fix them by restoring the page, 301-redirecting to the closest relevant page or asking the linking site to update the link. Do not redirect everything to the homepage.
What a broken backlink is
Someone links to yoursite.com/old-guide. You delete or rename that page. The link still exists on their site, but visitors now see a 404, and the value of the link is lost. It is one of the easiest link wins because the link already exists.
How to find them
- Search Console. Open Links, then Top linked pages (external). Check the listed URLs for errors.
- Backlink tools. Export links to your domain and filter for target URLs with a 404 status.
- Crawl your own site. Compare your current URL list with the linked URLs.
- Server logs. Look for 404s that have referrers from other sites.
Also check typos in links from other sites, such as a missing letter in your URL.
How to fix them
- Restore the page if it still has value.
- 301 redirect the old URL to the closest equivalent page. See recovering opportunity from 404 pages.
- Ask the site owner to update the link if the redirect is not possible.
- Avoid blanket redirects to the homepage. Google may treat irrelevant redirects like soft 404s.
Redirects can be added with a WordPress redirect plugin, .htaccess or your host's panel.
Related: broken links on your own pages
Broken outbound or internal links hurt user experience. See finding and fixing broken links. Reclaiming links to your site is the opposite direction, but the same crawl habit helps with both.
Make it a routine
Check after any redesign, migration or URL change. Keep a redirect map, and review top linked pages every quarter. See changing a domain without losing SEO for a bigger migration.
FAQs
What is a broken backlink?
A link from another site to a URL on your site that returns an error.
How do I find broken backlinks for free?
Use the Links report in Google Search Console and check the top linked pages.
Should I redirect every 404 to my homepage?
No. Redirect to the most relevant page.
Do broken backlinks hurt SEO?
The lost link value is the main cost, along with a poor visitor experience.
How long does it take to recover the link value?
After a redirect, Google needs to recrawl the old URL, which can take days to weeks.
Can I ask sites to fix links?
Yes, a polite email with the correct URL often works.
What is broken link building?
Finding broken links on other sites and offering your content as a replacement. It is related but different.
How often should I check?
Every quarter and after structural changes.
Conclusion
Find the broken backlinks, then redirect or restore the pages so the existing links keep working for you. A quarterly check in Search Console and a backlink tool is enough for most sites.
HostCloud helps Indian websites with reliable hosting, domains and support. See the options at https://hostcloud.in.
Sources: