What is ARC (Authenticated Received Chain) in email, and why does forwarding break DMARC?
TL;DR: ARC, or Authenticated Received Chain (RFC 8617), lets an intermediary such as a forwarder or mailing list record the authentication results it saw and sign them, so the final receiver can see that the message passed SPF, DKIM and DMARC before it was changed in transit. Forwarding often breaks SPF and alters content so DKIM fails. ARC does not make a message pass DMARC by itself, but receivers that trust the intermediary can use it to deliver legitimate forwarded mail.
The problem ARC solves
When mail is forwarded, the sending IP changes, so SPF fails. Mailing lists often add footers or change the subject, so the DKIM signature breaks. With a strict DMARC policy such as p=reject, that legitimate forwarded message can be rejected. See DMARC without breaking forwarding.
How ARC works
Each intermediary that supports ARC adds three headers:
- ARC-Authentication-Results. What it found when it received the message: SPF, DKIM and DMARC.
- ARC-Message-Signature. A signature of the message as it is now.
- ARC-Seal. A signature over the ARC headers that creates the chain.
Each hop gets an instance number (i=1, i=2 and so on), forming a chain. The final receiver checks the chain and decides whether to trust it.
What ARC does and does not do
- It records earlier results. It does not make a failing message pass.
- Receivers decide which ARC signers they trust, so ARC helps only with intermediaries they already trust.
- It does not replace SPF, DKIM or DMARC. Set those up first: SPF, DKIM and DMARC guide.
What site owners should do
Most small senders do not need to configure ARC themselves. Mailbox providers and mailing-list software add it. Your jobs are to:
- Sign mail with DKIM and publish SPF and DMARC.
- Use a DMARC policy you have tested. Start with
p=noneand monitor. - If you run a mailing list or forwarder yourself, enable ARC in the software.
- Read headers when debugging, to see whether the chain passed. See the email spam test guide.
Reading ARC headers
In a message's full headers, look for ARC-Seal, ARC-Message-Signature and ARC-Authentication-Results lines with i=1 onward. An arc=pass result in the final Authentication-Results header means the chain verified.
FAQs
What does ARC stand for?
Authenticated Received Chain.
Does ARC replace DMARC?
No. It works alongside it.
Do I need to configure ARC?
Usually not, unless you run forwarding or mailing-list software.
Why does forwarding fail SPF?
Because the message is sent from the forwarder's IP, which is not in your SPF record.
Does ARC guarantee delivery?
No. The receiver decides whether to trust the chain.
Which RFC defines ARC?
RFC 8617.
Who adds ARC headers?
Intermediaries such as mailbox providers and mailing lists.
How can I see if ARC passed?
Look for arc=pass in the Authentication-Results header.
Conclusion
ARC is a chain of signed records that lets legitimate forwarded mail keep its authentication story. Focus on your own SPF, DKIM and DMARC, and let intermediaries handle ARC.
HostCloud helps Indian websites with reliable hosting, domains and support. See the options at https://hostcloud.in.
Sources: